e. First off, the first bad thing she did was murder Ashfur in ThunderClan territory, which both belong to. So it was basically it was a same team kill.So here, Ashfur had an intent to kill Hollyleaf, Jayfeather and, Lionblaze, because he hated the "parents" Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw, but there was an intermarriage between two clan members of separate clans. So then Hollyleaf wanted to kill Ashfur because he knew the truth of the parents. The parents were Leafpool of ThunderClan and Crowfeather of WindClan. The question is that who went to the Dark Forest? Hollyleaf killed Ashfur because she wanted prove the secret, but, Ashfur wanted to kill the children of the cats, so it's hard to decide if both went to the Dark Forest, or if one actually did good.
Leave a comment on your opinion of who went to the Dark Forest
I say Hollyleaf is in the dark forest.
ReplyDeleteAshfur? Well....maybe, but, he was a loyal warrior to ThunderClan so long... and, technically he never even murdered any cat... although he did try to kill Firestar, didn't he? but also, I kind of understand why he wanted to kill Hollyleaf and Lionblaze and Jayfeather... the poor guy got left in the cold by Squirelflight, his sister had found a mate when she was really young, and he probably felt really lonely. Hollyleaf killed Ashfur so he wouldn't tell the Clans that she and her brothers are the children of Crowfeather and Leafpool... then she goes and tells everyone!!! Tell me that's not positively insane. Although, I guess insane cats aren't sent to the dark forest... just evil ones. But SURELY Jayfeather would have seen his own sister if she were in StarClan... I can't imagine Hollyleaf being in StarClan. Maybe... maybe she somehow is still alive, but if not, I think she's in the dark forest... or some other place... but not StarClan.
I don't think any of them are in the Dark Forest, though personally I despise Ashfur, though I agree with Strypes, he was a loyal ThunderClan warrior. But he did want to murder his clanmates... then again Hollyleaf DID murder her clanmate,.. I think she might've escaped through the tunnels before it collapsed, or maybe she's somewhere else, maybe in the ancient cats that lived near the lakes, maybe their ancestors hunting grounds, sorta like Feathertail with the tribe's ancestors, who she goes to StarClan AND the tribe of endless hunting.. that's just a thought though.
ReplyDelete